How to Fill Out Your Butler Preferences at Sandals Resorts: A Comprehensive Guide

Share Me!

You made the awesome decision to book a butler room at Sandals Resorts. Such a great way to pamper yourself and enhance your trip. But now you are curious as to how to fill out your butler preferences at Sandals Resorts. I know I was a little unsure the first time I had to do it, so today I am sharing tips to make it easier for you.

I love being a travel agent that specializes in Sandals Resorts because my husband and I also vacation there several times a year. So I can help you from both a business view and from personal experience. I know that the first time I filled out butler preferences, I didn’t have the foggiest idea what to do. My guess is you stumbled on my page because you were trying to figure it out too. Let’s go through it together!

Shoreline Journeys participates in affiliate marketing programs. I may receive a small commission from any purchases you make through links on this blog. Please see my full disclosure policy for more information.

Your butler is there to make your trip less stressful by handling a lot of details, making your vacation as relaxing and enjoyable as possible, and elevating your experience. But how do you ensure you get the most out of this unique service? Having your butler preferences at Sandals Resorts filled out before your trip is the first and most important step.

Where Do I Go To Fill Out My Butler Preferences At Sandals Resorts?

IMPORTANT UPDATE AS OF SEPTEMBER 2025: ALL BUTLER PREFERENCES MUST BE COMPLETED ON THE APP, AS THEY ARE UPDATING THE ONLINE SYSTEM. YOU WILL SEE THE SIMILAR SECTIONS ON THE APP. TO MAKE USING THE APP EASIER, PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING INSTRUCTIONS:

Take a look at the categories and create a word document. Once you have everything the way you want them, then input them into the app.

The first thing you need to do after booking your trip is to sign up for the Sandals Select Rewards program. As your travel agent, I make sure you do that as soon as we are done booking your trip. You will use that same email and password to sign into your butler preferences.

Then you will head over to the Sandals Butler preferences link to get started. As you can see, it will take you to the login page.

What Does The Butler Preference Form Do For Me?

First things first, what is this butler preferences form? The form allows you to communicate your likes, dislikes, and specific needs to your assigned butler before your arrival. It’s an essential step to ensure your stay is tailored just for you. The preferences form typically covers various categories, including food and beverage preferences, room setup, activities, and any special requests.

Do I Absolutely Need To Do This Before I Arrive On Resort?

Without a doubt, yes you do if you want to have the best possible experience! By filling out this form accurately, you’re setting your butler up for success. They want to know how to serve you best, so this is your chance to be as specific as possible! Think of it as your opportunity to communicate your vacation dreams and desires directly to the person who will help make them come true.

What’s Included In The Butler Preferences At Sandals Resorts

When you receive your butler preferences form, you’ll notice several categories to fill out. Let’s break down each section for clarity.

1. Food and Beverage Preferences

This is your chance to ensure your culinary experience is nothing short of spectacular!

• Dietary Restrictions: If you have any allergies or dietary restrictions (gluten-free, vegetarian, vegan, etc.), make sure to highlight them. For example, “I’m allergic to shellfish” or “I prefer a vegan diet” will help your butler suggest appropriate dining options. As your travel advisor, I will also clearly communicate to the resort about those needs.
• Favorite Cuisines: Do you love Italian, Caribbean, Asian, or perhaps a mix? Include your favorites! You could write, “I adore Italian food, especially pasta dishes.”
• Drink Preferences: Specify your favorite cocktails, wines, or non-alcoholic beverages. Something like, “I love mojitos and enjoy a glass of Chardonnay with dinner” will help your butler stock your room bar accordingly. For me, a chocolate martini is my go-to before dinner beverage. Our butlers at Sandals Dunn’s River got it right every single time!

2. Room Setup Preferences

Your comfort is extremely important when it comes to your butlers, and having the best possible room is part of that.

• Bedding Preferences: Do you prefer soft or firm pillows? Do you need a mattress topper? Are you cold all the time? Ask for extra blankets to be in your room. State your preferences clearly, and it will make for a better experience for all of you.
• Room Amenities: Do you prefer more bath products? Have allergies or sensitivities? Make them known before you ever set foot on the resort and you can be assured of a better experience.

3. Activities and Special Requests

Your butler is there to enhance your vacation experience, so let them know how to do it!

• Activity Preferences: Are you looking for adventure or relaxation? Perhaps you want to try scuba diving or book a couples’ massage. The butler staff can also help with arranging any tours by taking you to the Island Routes desk located on resort. I always recommend looking at the website prior to going so that you have an idea what you might want to do. As your travel agent, I can help you prebook these as well, especially if they are popular and may sell out quickly.
• Special Occasions: If you’re celebrating a birthday, anniversary, or honeymoon, make sure to inform them. This will help your butler arrange surprises, such as a special dinner or a room decoration. You might say, “We’re celebrating our anniversary—please arrange something special!”. Lots of the butlers will even set up a private dinner on your balcony or in your room, and having that on the butler preferences prior to arrival makes it that much easier for them to do that. One of the things I can do for you is prebook a candlelight dinner to celebrate your special event. Your butlers will coordinate it with the resort staff for a seamless experience.
• Mobility Issues: If you need the assistance of a golf cart or have difficulty walking, please note that in your butler preferences. Knowing that ahead of time can help the resort be prepared and your butler ready to help you out.

4. Communication Style

Your butler will want to know how best to communicate with you during your stay.

• Preferred Contact Method: Do you prefer a quick text or an in-person chat? Specify your preference to ensure smooth communication. When you stay in a butler room at Sandals, the butlers will give you a phone that you can use to call or text them. You don’t need to worry about wandering the resort to find them, and you can continue to enjoy the resort while you wait.
• Privacy Preferences: Some guests enjoy privacy, while others love chatting with their butler. Let them know your style. Most of the rooms have a doorbell system that includes a Do Not Disturb feature, and the butlers are trained to honor them.

When Do I Need To Submit My Butler Preferences?

Once you’ve filled out your preferences, it’s essential to submit them in a timely manner. Ideally, this should be done at least 4 weeks before your arrival but not later than 5 days prior. This allows your butler team ample time to prepare and stock your room according to your preferences. If you’re booking through a travel agent, they can often assist in submitting this form on your behalf.

Ask Your Butler For Feedback Once You Are On Resort

While it’s fantastic to fill out your preferences, don’t hesitate to be open-minded about new experiences! Your butler is a wealth of knowledge and can provide recommendations that enhance your stay. If they suggest trying a local dish or a unique activity that you didn’t think of, give it a shot! You might just discover a new favorite.

Once You Arrive On Resort, Here Are More Suggestions Regarding Your Butler Preferences

Upon your arrival, your butler will typically greet you, introduce themselves, and go over your preferences. This meeting is crucial, as it sets the tone for your relationship during your stay. Here are some tips for this initial conversation:

• Be Friendly and Warm: A smile goes a long way! When you meet your butler, greet them with a warm welcome. A friendly tone establishes a positive rapport.
• Review Your Preferences Together: Take this opportunity to discuss the preferences you filled out. For instance, you might say, “I’m really looking forward to the snorkeling trip we mentioned in the preferences form!” This reassures your butler that they have the correct information, and it opens the door for them to make additional suggestions.
• Clarify Expectations: If you have specific expectations about your stay, such as wanting to schedule certain activities at particular times, let your butler know. For example, “We’d love to have breakfast delivered to our room every morning around 9 AM. Is that doable?” Take the time to clarify and stress any potential food allergies as well. The more you communicate with your butlers, the better your experience will be.

Be understanding if they are unable to honor some of your requests. Sometimes supply chain issues prevent them from getting what you are requesting. It is a bummer, but it’s not their fault. Be patient and understanding. If it is something major, they will often contact your beforehand, so the sooner you submit your preferences, the sooner they can identify potential problems.

How To Handle Miscommunications Or Problems With Butler Preferences At Sandals Resorts

As you enjoy your stay, don’t hesitate to provide feedback to your butler. This will help them adjust their service to better meet your needs. Here’s how to do it gracefully:

• Positive Reinforcement: If your butler does something you appreciate, let them know! A simple, “Thank you for the lovely dinner arrangements, it was perfect!” can motivate them to continue providing excellent service. And when you tip your butlers at the end of your stay, they will know you are being truthful because you have been communicating with them throughout your stay.
• Constructive Feedback: If something isn’t quite right, approach the situation kindly. Instead of saying, “This isn’t what I wanted,” you could say, “I appreciate your effort, but I was hoping for a different dish. Could we try the grilled lobster next time?” They work hard to make sure all their couples are taken care of, but mistakes can happen. How you handle your response goes a long way and you will often find your butlers will end up being even more attentive after constructive feedback.

Always talk to your butler first about any problems with service. They are not mind readers and may not know what you are needing, especially if you were unclear in your pre-arrival butler preferences. Talking to them in a kind and gentle manner with clear expectations will go a long way to correcting any lapse in service.

If you still have problems with your butler team, please visit the lounge and ask to speak to the butler manager. Don’t run to social media and complain before you give them a chance to correct any miscommunications or misunderstandings. You can also use the GINA app on your phone to send concerns to the management staff.

I hope you found this information useful when it’s time to fill out your butler preferences at Sandals Resorts. Don’t forget you can reach out to me to help you with them as well. Ready to get your butler room booked? Reach out to me and I can help get you booked and on your way to paradise!

And I understand that you may not be ready to use a travel agent, and that’s okay. You can still book your vacation on your own through this link. Sandals Resorts will know that you found out about the resort through my website, but you will have full control of your booking. Just know that I can’t help if anything comes up, so booking with me is the absolute best way to go!

More Sandals Vacation Post You Will Find Useful

• Before Your Sandals Resorts Vacation Do These Things For A Great Trip
• Benefits Of Online Check-In At Sandals Resorts
• Your Complete Guide To Hurricane Safety At Sandals Resorts
• The Sandals & Beaches Travel Insurance Plan: What You Need To Know

Recommended Items To Make Your Sandals Resorts Vacation The Best Ever!

• K.Y.S.S. Locking Bag or Backpack
• Sum Bum Suntan Lotion
• Fun Towel Clips For Sun Loungers
• Go Pro Hero 13 Creators Edition
• Aqua 4-in-1 Monterey Hammock Pool Float & Water Hammocks

Share Me!